Prompt Post #4

[theoldguardkinkmeme]

To keep the prompt posts more manageable in size for modding, new prompts should be added in Prompt Post #5. 

This post remains open, however, for you to link fills or express your excitement over prompts you would like to see filled.

There are still many, many gorgeous prompts in this post that have not yet been written or drawn. For easier browsing, check out the Pinboard.

Remember: 

Any characters, any ship, any trope, any kink are welcome (with the sole exception of sexual scenarios involving human(oid) characters under 14). 

Each prompt gets a new comment directly under the post. Don't use threaded comments for new prompts. Only squee, encouragement, and links to fills go in the comments responding to individual prompts.

Prompts should be posted anonymously.

Please use a header with your character(s)/pairing and a keyword or short phrase (For example: "Andy/Quynh, Make-up sex" or "Nicky/Joe/Booker, first time DP").

Comments

Nicky/Joe + Alternate First Meeting During Manhunt

[(Anonymous)]

AU where the team is still immortal, but Nicky is the last one to join- he and Joe still met during the Crusades so they don't dream of each other at all. But Nile, Booker, and Andy do

+At first they think it's Merrick or Keane who's the immortal and they're complaining about letting some rich trust fund kid into their group. They see his labs and they see his penthouse and what looks like a woodland/forest area

++And then Nile sees Nicky. She sees him locked in Merrick's labs. Being used as a servant to clean Merrick's penthouse and cook for him. She sees him praying and being cut into when he isn't forced to play Cinderella

+++Copley's plan is to infiltrate Merrick's home, pretend like the team is a group of buyers willing to invest in the company and when they're sitting in Merrick's house, they catch glimpses of Nicky but Merrick's bodyguard is always quick to grab him and shove him away out of sight. Joe thinks he's seen Nicky from somewhere before but can't outright speak to Nicky alone

++++After dinner, Merrick takes the group into the forest area behind the penthouse and tells them they're going to play one of his favorite games: Man hunt. He gets out a bunch of weapons and his bodyguard drags Nicky out and the only thing they can do is play along but Andy sends Nicky a signal to let him know they're going to get him out- they end up playing the game, chasing Nicky through the woods like they're hunting an animal

After the game of Man hunt, they manage to get Nicky out and Joe realizes he knew Nicky from somewhere, and they reconnect and the team welcomes Nicky with open arms, Booker complaining that he was late to the party

Jafar/Nicolo, Aladdin fusion

[(Anonymous)]

Nicolo is either one of the princes who came to court prince Jasmine or a member of a royal family who’s accompanying the prince. Jafar sees him and decides that this princeling will be his and starts his own courtship.

AU with no homophobia please, where a royal Grand Vizier can absolutely pursue a prince if he wishes.

Re: Jafar/Nicolo, Aladdin fusion

[setos_puppy]

10/10

Would AU!Jafar still be evil or be more... cunning?

Joe/Nicky - pretending to be a couple

[(Anonymous)]

Yusuf and Nicolò have to pretend to be a couple. At this point, quite early in their relationship, neither considered the other as a potential romantic partner so it’s quite an eye-opener.
All the usual tropes welcome!

Re: Joe/Nicky - pretending to be a couple

[(Anonymous)]

Hardcore second.

Joe/Nicky, Joe is a virgin, Nicky’s experienced

[(Anonymous)]

Not that I don’t enjoy it the other way around, but in the interest of balance, give me a Nicolo who fucked his way through half of Genova before he left for the Crusades and a chaste Yusuf who’s saving himself for marriage (or at least true love).

Re: Joe/Nicky, Joe is a virgin, Nicky’s experienced

[(Anonymous)]

Amen amen amen!

Joe/Nicky - pretending to be a couple with dubcon!

[(Anonymous)]

A twist on the above prompt. Nicolò and yusuf have to pretend to be a couple and in order to fool the people they are trying to fool, they have to have sex with one another. It’s awkward but one of them is more experienced than the other and guides them through it. Angst with a happy ending.

No public sex or voyeurism, they are in private but know they are being monitored closely enough to better not risk pretending.

Joe/Nicky, Joe/Team

[(Anonymous)]

Sometimes Nicky really enjoys sharing Joe. Safe, sane and consensual, every member of their team gets a go. Restraints, blindfolds, vibes and pegging are all loved, but not necessary! ❤️

+ If someone really likes Joe's mouth. It's a nice mouth. It deserves to be wrecked.

++ Aftercare please ;_;

Based on this awesome prompt, and it's wonderful filler
https://theoldguardkinkmeme.dreamwidth.org/1106.html?thread=89938#cmt89938

Re: Joe/Nicky, Joe/Team

[(Anonymous)]

Author anon who filled the other prompt hears you and will get to this ASAP in the next couple days :) just let me know if there are any other special things you’re hoping to see!

Nicky/Joe - Both of them are trans

[(Anonymous)]

Both Nicky and Joe are trans, either both MtF, FtM, or one is MtF and one is FtM. Am interested in both of them being comfortable with their bodies and the different ways they talk and treasure each other.

kthx bye

Nile + everyone, gen, oh no they’re hot!

[(Anonymous)]

Nile is used to seeing the others in plain shirts, jeans, tactical gear, with whatever hair.
The Old Guard has to infiltrate a high society function so they all have to dress up to the nines. Nile is shocked - shocked!- to discover that she never realised she’s surrounded by ridiculously attractive people.
She really wants to stop staring, but would you?

Booker/Nile - Slowly falling in love

[(Anonymous)]

After his return from exile, Booker and Nile start to bond over their lost families and their love of their new one. Friendship slowly turns to love.

Re: Booker/Nile - Slowly falling in love

[(Anonymous)]

Seconding this!

Quynh/Joe, Voyeurism, Fucking for their partners' benefit

[(Anonymous)]

Set back in the good ol'days, Andromache loves watching Yusuf and Quynh go at it. They're gorgeous together, and Quynh always puts on a bit of a show. She loves watching Quynh come and licking her spend off of Yusuf's cock or face or thighs.

Nicolo does not love it. He spends the entire time white knuckled and breathing hard, it's the worst way to tease himself but what he loves best, is taking Yusuf when he's wrecked and trembling, and fucking him through the floor.

Bonus if Joe can be nice and reassuring and worried that Nicky's insecure, but Nicky's not worried. He will take some fussing if Joe's offering tho kthnx

Re: Quynh/Joe, Voyeurism, Fucking for their partners' benefit

[(Anonymous)]

this is an amazing prompt!

Joe/Nicky h/c, Joe is forcibly shaved by villain

[(Anonymous)]

Basically any scenario where the villain shaves Joe's head and beard. Honestly inspired by how they sheered Aslan's mane to humiliate him in Chronicles of Narnia. It's a loss of agency and the villain, Joe and Nicky all know that.

+ Joe feeling foolish about this upsetting him, of all things, but Nicky reassuring him that it makes sense for him to feel violated and comforting him in the aftereffects of it.

Re: Joe/Nicky h/c, Joe is forcibly shaved by villain

[(Anonymous)]

Yes this all of this.

Andy & team, regaining immortality

[(Anonymous)]

Every time I think about a point in the future when Andy’s not around, it bums me out, so let’s have her somehow regain her immortality for Reasons. Maybe she’s already noticed that she’s healing a little faster again, so she had an inkling, but the others haven’t noticed yet and so when she gets killed on a mission, they’re absolutely distraught, thinking she’s really gone. And then she wakes up.

Can be with polyamorous team or just a platonic Guard that’s very happy and relieved that Andy is okay and is going to be sticking around for the foreseeable future.

Bonus points if it’s still while Booker is in exile but one of the others calls him to tell him that she has her immortality back, because they may still be pissed at him but they’re not cruel, and he cries on the phone because even if they make him serve the whole hundred years, he’s going to get to see Andy again.

Joe/Nicky - 69

[(Anonymous)]

Nice!

Re: Joe/Nicky - 69

[(Anonymous)]

I was gonna request this!! Hell yeah!

Joe/Nicky/Booker - Ageplay

[(Anonymous)]

Look he's their littlest brother, and sometimes he likes to drop and be taken care of by his big brothers.

Not looking for infantalism bc that's not my thing, but on the sort of wretched naughtiness the three sometimes feel when they call each other brother and croon about protecting each other.

Nicky/Joe - dramatic rescue

[(Anonymous)]

Upon realizing he's in love with Joe, Nicky leaves the team and enters a strict monastery because of extreme gay panic reasons.

Cue Joe barging in one night and rescuing him in the most over the top fashion.

Angry monks pursue. History books still talk about that.

Re: Nicky/Joe - dramatic rescue

[highsmith]

Y E S

Nicky/Joe - sexual disfunction due to meds

[(Anonymous)]

Modern AU where one of them starts taking antidepressants and it seriously affects their sex life.

It's hard to have an erection or to achieve orgasm or they just dont feel like having sex at all. No easy fix. It's a problem and they need to work through it.

Re: Nicky/Joe - sexual disfunction due to meds

[(Anonymous)]

Would love to see this!

Poly!Guard - MDA/MDMA and a cuddle puddle

[setos_puppy]

I don't care if it's an AU where Booker never left, where Nile is there, where even Quynh and Lykon are there. All I want is these beautiful dumbasses high and in love and snuggling and cuddling.

Joe/Nicky - power imbalance

[(Anonymous)]

Any scenario in which there’s build in power imbalance between these two, for example teacher/student, boss/secretary, director/actor, master/servant etc. It’s inappropriate but too alluring for both of them to ignore it.
Massive bonus if one is calling the other by their surname and/or rank/title the entire time.

There’s no coercion, I’m looking for a sexy, tropey version of this scenario.

Nicky/Joe - solo play, vouyerism

[(Anonymous)]

One of them is out on a mission and the other is left home alone or at the safehouse and wanting. They decide to pull out their fave toy(s) and try to take the edge off. Whomever was away returns and delights in catching the other and sits off to the side and talks them through to an orgasm.

Re: Nicky/Joe - solo play, vouyerism Filled

[(Anonymous)]

Op, your fill (with a side of mirrors): https://theoldguardkinkmeme.dreamwidth.org/694.html?thread=459702#cmt459702

Joe/Nicky Ritual Sex

[(Anonymous)]

Either of them loses their immortality. Someone finds this old ritual to bond life forces together/grant immortality/prolong life. They don’t have confirmation that it ever worked, but they do have a couple of ingredients that are hard to come by, like the semen of an immortal, or the blood of a thousand slain enemies (or something else, go wild!)

cue ritualistic sex, where one fucks the immortality back into the other

+ the more complicated the ritual the better
++ if there’s a public sex element to it, with other people baring witness
+++ if there’s an altar involved to collect the blood and/or semen
+++ equally into a bowl to collect and them drinking/sharing
++++ both of them being completely swept away by the ritual (which can involve aphrodisiacs/sex pollen/heat like symptoms/sex magic, or just them being into it…) and ending up in a fucking frenzy

I prefer the ritual to work and neither of them to die permanently, but I’m not opposed to temporary death (before or during the ritual) and temporary mortality to increase the stakes.

Re: Joe/Nicky Ritual Sex

[(Anonymous)]

Please! Ritualistic sex is one of my absolute weaknesses!!

Joe/Nicky, anal fingering + butt plugs + anal sex

[(Anonymous)]

Having a body that constantly heals itself means that every time Joe fucks Nicky, even if it's multiple times in one night, it feels like the first time all over again. It also means that he has to spend a lot of time opening him up for it between rounds, which Joe thinks is hot as hell because he loves the sounds Nicky makes when he's riding his fingers, but sometimes he wishes he could keep Nicky's hole open and ready for him whenever he wants it. The discovery of the butt plug is a serious game changer.

(I h/c them as verse, but for the purposes of the prompt I'm feeling some bottom Nicky pls)

Re: Joe/Nicky, anal fingering + butt plugs + anal sex

[(Anonymous)]

I am pro your kink and support you! I just want to clarify for anyone reading this who might be into anal or trying anal in the future: being loose or stretched for anal is not the same as damage that needs healing (at least in real life, in a fantasy world to make this kink happen it can be!). Stay safe out there while enjoying butts, kids!

Booker & Vidocq, Napoleonic France shenanigans

[(Anonymous)]

This is super random and specific but the idea won’t leave me alone! So in Napoleonic France there was this guy called Eugène-François Vidocq (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugène_François_Vidocq), who was one of the inspirations for Javert in Les Miserables and had a fascinating life.

Vidocq—born five years after Booker—was a French thief, forger and army deserter who formed a unit of secret agents within the Parisian police called the Sûreté, mostly composed of other ex-criminals. Probably because they were former criminals, the Sûreté was actually super successful at reducing crime! There was a whole movie about Vidocq a couple years ago (trailer here if you’re interested: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KacFlzRKfeg)

Anyway, the prompt is that Booker was a member of Vidocq’s Sûreté. Do with that what you will!

Joe/Nicky, caretaking, bathing

[(Anonymous)]

Joe went out on a mission and returned days/weeks later completely exhausted, dirty, unkept etc
Nicky takes care of him: baths him, feeds him, shaves him, puts him to bed etc.

The Old Guard Team + Coming Across Other Immortals

[(Anonymous)]

Imagine the team meeting immortal people from other pieces of media?

-When they meet Merlin (BBC Merlin) Merlin thinks Booker is Arthur at first cuz if the blond hair and they realize they were dreaming about him, but in their dreams he was a young man with black hair and blue eyes and a red neckerchief in Camelot and they wonder how he aged so rapidly when none of them have

-Jack Harness (Doctor Who/Torchwood) is definitely immortal in the terms the team understand it to be but then they wonder why he's so adamant about carrying around a hand in a jar like it holds the secrets of the universe (which in The Torchwood universe it dies considering he deals with aliens on a day to day basis)

-Deadpool is just way too much for them to handle but Andy loves his fighting because he gets the job done

-Maybe they meet non human immortals too, like Davy Jones from pirates of the Caribbean and they're like what the fuck are we dreaming of why is there a squid man or Ryuk from Death Note which is weird because no one else can see him and all their apples keep disappearing

-Nathan Young from Misfits- he's an absolute idiot and loud and brash and he takes a liking to them but they didn't expect to come across his coffin while visiting Booker's family graves that one time and it takes some time.gettingnused to his jokes and personality. Nile doesn't think she's seen Nicky pray so much for one person not to get smited or something

Joe/Nicky, Buff Joe and Overwhelmed Nicky

[(Anonymous)]

Inspired by Marwan in Wolf and the Men's Health vid. Joe goes undercover as a boxer for a job and gets super-buff. Nicky is away (either doing recon or on another mission entirely) and returns to find Joe's stacked. Cue Nicky being overwhelmed and horny all the time and needing Joe to fucking him into the mattress and/or against any available surface yesterday!

Re: Joe/Nicky, Buff Joe and Overwhelmed Nicky

[(Anonymous)]

We have a lot in common because i'M CRAVING THIS