Prompt Post #4

[theoldguardkinkmeme]

To keep the prompt posts more manageable in size for modding, new prompts should be added in Prompt Post #5. 

This post remains open, however, for you to link fills or express your excitement over prompts you would like to see filled.

There are still many, many gorgeous prompts in this post that have not yet been written or drawn. For easier browsing, check out the Pinboard.

Remember: 

Any characters, any ship, any trope, any kink are welcome (with the sole exception of sexual scenarios involving human(oid) characters under 14). 

Each prompt gets a new comment directly under the post. Don't use threaded comments for new prompts. Only squee, encouragement, and links to fills go in the comments responding to individual prompts.

Prompts should be posted anonymously.

Please use a header with your character(s)/pairing and a keyword or short phrase (For example: "Andy/Quynh, Make-up sex" or "Nicky/Joe/Booker, first time DP").

Comments

Joe/Nicky, use of the safeword

[(Anonymous)]

Please give me bottom!Nicky needing to use the safeword during sex for whatever reason. After, he feels guilty because they had to stop, and Joe feels guilty as well because he thinks he should've been more careful or something. The way I see it, this can only end in a cuddle fest, but it's really up to you 😁

Fic: Safe [Re: Joe/Nicky, use of the safeword]

[(Anonymous)]

The word sliced through the air as sharp as a sword through skin. Joe came to an abrupt stop.

Moments ago his body had been burning with desire, ramming into Nicky as if he could actually leave an imprint on his lover's soul. His hand was tight around Nicky's wrists, which were bound above his head with soft silk. Joe still had one hand gripping Nicky's thigh, keeping his leg hitched up just for that extra minuscule amount of space to bring them closer.

This would be something to laugh about later, how Nicky could go from quiet pleasure to pushy and demanding. How Joe's mouth went from poetic to obscene. They'd laugh at themselves, blush and joke and then fall into soft kisses, falling asleep in an age old embrace.

That one word though. It had changed everything. This whole scene felt so sordid to Joe now. He was still deep inside Nicky, panting over him, shock taking the place of arousal. Nicky was still, too pale, eyes fixed on Joe as if he was waiting for a more substantial response.

Finally, Joe breathlessly said, "Nicolo."

That broke the awful spell. Nicky's blank expression crumbled, his mouth turning down, his eyes brightening quick before squeezing shut. Joe watched as Nicky's fingers curled and trembled.

Joe shook his head at himself, snapping out of the shock of the moment. He ran a soft hand down Nicky's flank, shushing him as he pulled out of his body and climbed off him to move to his side, making quick work of untying the binds.

Nicky pressed his unmoving hands to his face, breathing wetly and sniffing as Joe knelt there by his side. "Nicolo," Joe breathed, using older and sweeter words to coax Nicky from whatever pain had him trapped for the moment. "Speak to me. My love."

Nicky drew a breath as if he might speak, but the words seemed to crumble inside him and all he managed was a stifled sob. Joe put a hand on his head, combed his fingers through Nicky's hair.

Had he done something? Crossed some line with ill chosen words, with a touch too possessive? He had promised he'd never hurt Nicky, that he would step in the way of any pain about to be inflicted on his Niccolo. And yet, here they were, in their bed, like this.

"Tell me what I can do," Joe said. "Please, Nicolo."

Nicky took a few shuddering breaths, deep and painful it seemed, before looking at Joe with tears still running down from the corners of his eyes and into his hair. He reached out a hand and murmured, "Yusuf."

Joe went to him immediately, bending down to let Nicky wrap his arms around Joe's shoulders. Joe murmured all his names for Nicolo into his ear, all the languages he knew just an excuse to call Nicolo his. My love, he said. My beloved. My life. My everything. My child, my baby, he said, and Nicolo finally let out a wet laugh, telling Joe he was mad.

Joe pulled back, telling Nicky earnestly, "For you. Yes."

Nicky swallowed, nodding, telling Joe he loved him, telling Joe, 'you belong to me, mine forever' in sweet Italian, 'I love you, I love you.'

Joe kissed him, sweet and chaste, softly asking, "What do you want to do? Sleep?"

Nicky made a face and shook his head. "I need to breathe."

Joe nodded, helped him out bed, watching closely as Nicky dressed. It was late, three in the morning, and the world was pitch black outside, the stars enjoying their seclusion as much as Nicky and Joe did here, their hideaway from everything and everyone.

They walked down the hill, the ocean glimmering in the distance, the sound of waves gentle and soothing in their ears. Joe had his arm wrapped tight around Nicky's arm, glancing at him occasionally, sometimes in worry, sometimes just to see his moonlit profile. Immortality should have meant nothing changed, but by the grace of Allah, Nicky only seemed to grow more beautiful.

Their walk came to an end when they found a spot to sit and look at the beautiful black skin of the ocean, the moonlight's gaze falling upon it adoringly.

Joe brought Nicky's hand to his mouth, kissing Nicky's knuckles, kissing his palm. Nicky watched him, smiling gently. "Adore you," Joe said, or rather, reminded him.

"And I you," Nicky whispered. He looked sad though. Mournful.

"What's in your head?" Joe asked softly. "Did I do something?"

"Never," Nicky said quickly. "You could never hurt me. Not you."

"What then?" Joe asked.

"I was somewhere else for a moment," Nicky said, staring at the ocean. "Dying. Being killed. I don't want to think of such things, not when I'm with you, not in our bed. Why did it have to come into my mind? Why did it have to sully us?"

Joe scowled at him, letting out a laugh. "Nicolo. We are immortal, but we are still human. Your mind will not warn you before it hurts you. And...nothing can sully us. Nothing can sully what I feel for you."

Nicky snorted, but his smile caught the moonlight and Joe knew his mood was lifting. He gave Joe a look, keeping his thoughts to himself and then sighed and moved closer, shifting to lie down with his head in Joe's lap. Joe looked down, smiling happily, cupping Nicky's face.

"Do you think we were cruel to Booker?" Nicky asked.

"He left with all his body parts intact, so no," Joe said sweetly. Nicky rolled his eyes. Joe shrugged. "Yes. No. Maybe. I think what he did to us was also perhaps a little cruel, no?"

Nicky was quiet, his eyes glittering as bright as the stars. "No."

"No?"

"If I didn't have you..." Nicky said quietly. "What would I do without you?"

Joe thought about it. "I think you would grow a beard. Probably wear sandals. I think you would shout at children too."

Nicky laughed, shaking his head. Sighing, he said, "I think I would just stop. Death would have no choice but to take me."

"Stop this," Joe said, bending down and pressing a kiss to Nicky's mouth. "I am here. You are here."

"And Andy is dying," Nicky said thickly.

"She's not dying,"Joe said. "She is mortal. She is growing old. She is not dead yet. Please don't mourn her before her time. She would hate that."

Nicky let out a tired sight, covering his face with his hands as Joe leaned back and watched Nicky. When Nicky pulled his hands away, he looked at Joe and said, "I'm sorry. Tonight was supposed to be...devilish and filthy."

Joe grinned. "We have many nights to be devilish and filthy."

Nicky reached for the opening of Joe's jacket, pulling him down and sadly telling him, "But I wanted tonight."

"My poor Nicolo," Joe murmured against Nicky's mouth, smiling against his smile. Giving their surroundings a careful look, he said, "The night is not yet over. It's been a while since you ravaged me against a tree."

Nicky laughed into the next kiss. Cupping Joe's cheek he said, "Perhaps another night. Now I just want to go home."

"Anything you want," Joe said, pulling Nicky close and holding him tight for just a little while before they stood up and made their way home, hand in hand.

Nicky/Joe + Undercover Eurovision Mission

[(Anonymous)]

Ok so I'm American so some parts of it I don't fully get like scoring but I am a big fan of Eurovision and I just saw the Netflix movie as well as They Call Me Jeeg and Luca can SING so I want to see the team having to go on an undercover mission at Eurovision

+Nicky is the contestant representing for Italy, Nile is given the position of techie and Andy does costumes to be able to bug the other contestants for the info they need

++Booker and Joe are undercover as the competition commentators and Booker is just like kill me now because Joe does not miss an opportunity to wax poetic about Nicky now that he's been given a microphone an audience of almost a million people who have no choice but to listen to him

+++After the contest, Joe and Nicky actually make headlines because now the whole world thinks that Italy's contestant and the commentator are banging and the media can't seem to find them anywhere online (thanks to Copley) but there are plenty of headlines about Joe's dynamic with Booker as well- someone got a picture printed of Joe and Booker sitting in the booth and Joe is looking lovesick and ecstatic while Booker is depicted like he wants to crawl in a hole and die while chugging a flask he snuck past security

Re: Nicky/Joe + Undercover Eurovision Mission

[(Anonymous)]

LMAO would love to read this

Immortal!Keane/Nicky (non-con) - civilians save Nicky

[(Anonymous)]

At some point after Immortal!Keane has joined the team, the team is hiding in plain sight by living in the suburbs and pretending to be civilians between missions. They live as a family and befriend the neighbors to fit in. When the rest of the team is out of the house, Keane sees an opportunity to try to hurt Nicky. One, or more, of the neighbors hear Nicky's sounds of distress and intervenes and stops the assault. I just would love some normal people caring about Nicky and coming to his rescue.

+ Keane and Joe pretend to be brothers as part of their civilian identity, so the neighbor is extra horrified to find Keane assaulting his sweet brother-in-law
++ Nicky crying and being comforted by one of the neighbors, and Nicky being touched that someone he's known for a short while cares about him so much

Joe/Nicky, sounding

[(Anonymous)]

Nicky's cock is so pretty, Joe can't help but want to fuck it

bonus points if Nicky has something in his ass/mouth too

Re: Joe/Nicky, sounding

[(Anonymous)]

Yes please!!!

Booker/Joe/Nicky, Booker is captured, Non-Con

[(Anonymous)]

Booker is captured, either during his exile or when the team is together.
When he wakes, he is tied, blindfolded, his ears plugged and naked.
He expects to be raped, but he doesn't expect it to be so... gentle.
He is thoroughly used for days, but whoever is doing that to him touches him with soft, soothing hands and no violence. that's makes it almost worse.

When he gets rescued, those samehands remove his blindfold and ties and he realizes that Nicky and Joe were with him the whole time.

It was never about Booker. The bad guys wanted to use Booker to break Joe and Nicky, threatening to have him raped by all their men if Joe and Nicky didn't do it themselves. Joe and Nicky took care of him the only way they could until they managed to break free.

+ Aftercare, bathing, forgiveness
++ nightmares and snuggling for safety

Re: Booker/Joe/Nicky, Booker is captured, Non-Con

[(Anonymous)]

Crying over this perfect prompt

joe/nicky, nicky's head gets taken as a trophy

[(Anonymous)]

Heya, sorry I accidentally posted on #3 please ignore that!

Era of your choice. Nicky gets beheaded and bad guy of the week decides to take his head as a trophy.
The body doesn't seem to be healing so it gets buried.
Team is unsure how healing works in this scenario (either no one has gotten beheaded or they always put the head back on or smth befor).
When the head doesn't reanimate they think nicky is perma dead.
Meanwhile nicky has to dig out of a grave.

(Would also be up for any reverse scenarios where the head grows the body back or lit anything as long as nicky get's beheaded and it takes awhile!)
Thank you and have a great day!

Re: joe/nicky, nicky's head gets taken as a trophy

[(Anonymous)]

Omg yes! Please!

Joe/Nicky, Joe has a stalker

[(Anonymous)]

In the Renaissance, or your choice of time frame, Joe's artistic ways won him a lot of praise, and the attention of a pushy admirer. Someone who didn't understand that Joe was being polite or friendly, someone who feels like he knows the artist more than the world deserves to.

He follows Joe to his studio, to his home. He's too friendly. He's too possessive.

One day he goes overboard, and Nicky comes home to find him raping Joe in their bed.

Bonus if he somehow managed to kill Nicky, send him away before finding Joe.

Bonus bonus if the stalker is a powerful man like a governor or general, someone who can be a threat!

Re: Joe/Nicky, Joe has a stalker

[(Anonymous)]

Wow, this got really dark, so - yes please!

Nicky/Jo. Serious falling out for their 1,000th anniversary

[(Anonymous)]

Nicky and Joe, yin and yang - the thoughtful, grounded and kind aesthetic paired with the passionate and creative sirocco wind - their love has endured almost 1,000 years until Joe mentions in passing the name of his long dead wife. A wife that Nicky had never heard about before.

Nicky feels betrayed, why had Joe never mentioned he had a wife? Nicky has never felt sexually attracted to a woman - it undermines his faith in Joe’s love for him.

Joe is nonplussed as to nicky’s hurt - that part of his life is long gone, it was an arranged yet happy marriage - and if he deliberately didn’t tell Nicky in the early years it was because he was worried the still deeply religious Nicolo would have sent him home back to her.

I’d love angst, confusion, misunderstanding, maybe some physical violence, separation hurt/comfort, perhaps Nicky deciding to sleep with a woman with a great NSFW coming back together. Whatever those with the great gift of writing decide to bestow!

Re: Nicky/Jo. Serious falling out for their 1,000th anniversary

[(Anonymous)]

yes!!!

Nicky/Joe, arranged marriage, royalty AU

[(Anonymous)]

Prince Nicolò is engaged to be married to Prince Yusuf. He hates everything about this: he doesn’t speak the language, doesn’t know the culture and was told since he was a child that these people are barbarians to be conquered. He’d rather go back to his monastery.

Bunch of bonuses:
+ Yusuf hates the idea of being married to a virgin. What is so wrong with Nicolò that nobody had wanted him, not even once?
+ awkward wedding night
+ seduction via poetry and gifts
+ Nicolò realising that no, these people aren’t barbarians, in many ways they are much more cultured than his people

Re: Nicky/Joe, arranged marriage, royalty AU

[(Anonymous)]

+ Yusuf hates the idea of being married to a virgin. What is so wrong with Nicolò that nobody had wanted him, not even once?

OH!

Yes,please!

Joe/Nicky, Andy/Quynh + Andy & Quynh Come Across Joe and Nicky being attacked by bandits

[(Anonymous)]

Andy and Quynh are on their way to meet Joe and Nicky because they can't stop dreaming about them when they come across a small camp that has been almost destroyed. A small campfire, a tent that's been slashed and the belongings strewn about.

The two women watch from a safe distance as the bandits go through it and then they see the bandits pulling Joe out of the tent. The bandits are threatening him, pilfering through his sketchbooks that Andy has seen him draw in in her dreams countless times and they're holding him back from the tent even as he's screaming for the other man they saw in their dreams- but Nicky isn't incoming out of the tent and they saw other bandits go into the tent as well

So Andy and Quynh deduce what's happening and rush in, weapons drawn and save Joe. Then Andy goes inside the tent to get Nicky and finds the other bandits holding him down and tearing at his clothes and threatening to rape him while Nicky is screaming for Joe and Andy makes quick work before the bandits can really do anything- when they come.out of the tent, Andy has Nicky wrapped in her cloak (the bandits ripped his clothes quite badly) and she watches how these two men cling to each other, speaking soft and rushed and worried

Once back at their own camp, Quynh and Andy discuss what happened in the tent while Joe and Nicky are asleep because Quynh hadn't seen Andy so shaken up before

Andy/Quynh/Nile, orgasm denial

[(Anonymous)]

One of them? All of them? I'm not fussed.

Bonus points for a slow burn (I.E. over the course of a day, not just one encounter).

Fill: Andy/Quynh/Nile, orgasm denial

[(Anonymous)]

Filled here!


https://theoldguardkinkmeme.dreamwidth.org/694.html?thread=756406#cmt756406

Joe & Nile, Nile cuts Joe's hair

[(Anonymous)]

I've read a few wonderful fics where Joe learns how to take care of Nile's hair, and I'd love to see the opposite, too.

+ Nile and her brother used to help with each-other's hair, so Nile knows how to deal with hair similar to Joe's, so the act of cutting it helps her feel close to her brother while also bonding with Joe.
++++ Joe had a Bad Experience with someone touching/ripping/cutting his hair against his will (see: earlier prompt) and now only lets Nicky cut it. Nile doesn't know this (maybe Joe tells it to her later), but Nicky gets geniuinely emotional and touched that Joe trusts Nile enough to do this, and Nile is very confused as to why.
++++++++ A Joe and Nile hug in there somewhere after connecting over the fact that Hair Can Be Something So Personal, Actually.

Re: Joe & Nile, Nile cuts Joe's hair

[(Anonymous)]

Ahh this is a cute one! I like! Between this and that amazing art fill of Joe and Nile painting each other's nails, never mind Nicky getting emotional, I'M getting emotional for all this Joe & Nile bonding content!!!

Booker/anyone, shame kink/praise kink

[(Anonymous)]

Post-exile Booker needs to be shamed before he's praised. I don't care who does it.

I'd prefer it if the shaming was in reference to his exile/his actions rather than derogatory language.

I'd really love cuddling, post-scene and honest discussions.

Joe/Nicky - Heavy BDSM, Humiliation, Degradation

[(Anonymous)]

Nicky is Joe's submissive, and when they're not on a mission, they show those roles. Set after the movie and Nile getting used to seeing Nicky naked, wearing only a collar, and wrist and ankle cuffs. Joe keeps Nicky plugged, with his cock caged. Nicky sits at Joe's feet while he's sketching, and if Joe needs to piss, he tells Nicky "Toilet", and Nicky gets Joe's cock out and drinks his piss.

Nicky gets to eat, but only after Joe has cum on his food. Joe often cums on Nicky's face and doesn't allow him to wash it off. Humiliation and degradation are heavily involved in their relationship, and Nicky is punished heavily if he doesn't do something to Joe's liking.

Nile doesn't understand how Nicky can allow but he tells her his submission to Joe is exactly what he needs it to be.

Joe/Nicky, slutshaming and defence

[(Anonymous)]

Joe and Nicky are in a relationship where they are open to sleeping with other people, although Nicky isn't interested so he rarely does it, but he doesn't mind at all that Joe has fun because they are very secure in their 900 years of love. But someone else (another member of the team if you wish, or Copley, or an outsider entirely) slut shames Joe and Nicky rises passionately to his defence.

(Honestly, if the author prefers to flip it I can see it the other way too, because Joe is a drippy romantic who only has eyes for his Nicolo 95% of the time but if someone ever dares question Nicky's love for him it is gloves OFF TIME TO FITE.)

Joe/Nicky: any timeline + insecurity, low self-esteem

[(Anonymous)]

Just looking for some good ol’ insecurity, low self-esteem and internal struggles from Nicky. He knows he lacks a few skills at relationships and he’s great in bed for Joe, but he has those low days on how he feels about himself. Nicky is a very good looking man, but sometimes he just doesn’t feel like that. Cue in Joe and his loving words, gentle hands and His limitless love.

Feel free to add and do whatever you want with this one! Just make sure it’s purely nicky/joe :)

Joe/Nicky - Greaser!Joe

[(Anonymous)]

Set in the 1950s in either American or Britain, Joe adopts the greaser look to blend in on recon missions (maybe something with early Cold War era if you need a reason for a mission?). Nicky finds it utterly distracting.

The tight jeans, the white shirt, the leather jacket, the motorcycle and muscle cars? Nicky can't help it, he's only human.

+ Bonus for undercover factory!worker or mechanic andy who wears pants.

Booker/Nile foot massage

[(Anonymous)]

Can be erotic or gen.
Nile is stressed or her feet hurt from walking all day.
Booker wips out the oil and shows some unexpected talent.

Re: Booker/Nile foot massage

[setos_puppy]

*kicks in door*

DID SOMEONE SAY FOOT MASSAGE?

Hello this is my thing. I am here for you anon. Are you alright with them being in a pre-established relationship? Are you alright with other forms of foot fetish? Ie: Mouth worship, foot jobs, etc?

Are you alright with D/s tones as in Booker being Nile's kept boy, basically.

Also, I have a AU verse where the whole group is poly, would you be okay with me placing it in that?

Joe/Nicky, Hickeys

[(Anonymous)]

Joe loves Nicky's neck and biting into it, but any hickeys heal instantly. Doesn't mean Joe can't spend hours sucking bruises on it.

Either desperate Nicky or indifferent but secretly hot for it Nicky.

Re: Joe/Nicky, Hickeys Filled

[(Anonymous)]

Fill for you!
https://theoldguardkinkmeme.dreamwidth.org/694.html?thread=447414#cmt447414

Joe/Nicky -- Nicky in panties

[(Anonymous)]

Nicky might not be the best dressed member of the guard, but underneath he definitely has the prettiest panties.

Joe's a big fan

Re: Joe/Nicky -- Nicky in panties

[setos_puppy]

yes yes yes

Joe/Nicky, absolutely wrecking Nicky's ass in Marrakesh

[(Anonymous)]

Nicky's limping in the baklava scene. (No, really, go look!) Tell us why, anons.

TELL US WHY.

Re: Joe/Nicky, absolutely wrecking Nicky's ass in Marrakesh

[(Anonymous)]

Yes yes yesssssss

Andy/Quynh/Booker, death by snu-snu

[(Anonymous)]

Quynh's back, she and Andy are an item again, and they fuck Booker to death (he gets better). It's honestly one of the top five greatest experiences of his life.

Andy/[Nicky], appeasing the goddess Andromache

[(Anonymous)]

Andy's a wrathful(?) goddess, Nicky's the virgin(??) sacrifice.

Is he unwilling? Did he volunteer? Is he scared? Is he hoping he dies?

More importantly: does she take him herself, or does she delegate her chief priest and drinking buddy, Yusuf?

Re: Andy/[Nicky], appeasing the goddess Andromache

[(Anonymous)]

ooooooh

seconded!
(especially that bit about chief priest Yusuf)

Joe/Nicky, Nicky becomes Joe's Guardian Angel/Watcher

[(Anonymous)]

So on the angst train. Consider the following Nicky doesn't get back up from being shot in the head when the group is escaping the lab. Everyone thinks he has fully gone and Joe basically loses it. They basically go to a safehouse and try to regroup with Joe barely going on and only staying barely alive to honor the memory of his husband.

What no one knows is that Nicky's soul remains behind with Joe as his own personal guardian angel (whether thats full on white wings and a halo or just as a type of spiritual guardian is up to the writer). He cannot touch anything in the physical world, no one can hear or see him. He basically considers it his duty to watch after Joe and be there for him even when his husband does not know it.

However, whenever Joe dies and his soul is in the veil they can see, hear and touch each other. Although Joe thinks he is dreaming.

This continues on with Joe getting into riskier and more intense deaths in order to see the other half of his soul until some death keeps him dead long enough for Nicky to have a conversation with Joe explaining he's basically still there just intangible.

Que Joe and the group looking into ways to make Nickytangible or connected to the mortal coil (through some sort of ritual)

The story can start whenever I would ultimately just like it to conclude with Nicky becoming tangible in all ways until its Joes time. Also the story can be whatever rating the writer wants. :D

+1 Please feel free to make the story angsty and whumpy
+10 Would love if the ritual involves tying Joe and Nicky's souls together since they are soulmates
+100 joe waxes poetic in his own joe way about how Nicky literally became an angel on earth for him or heaven on earth

Re: Joe/Nicky, Nicky becomes Joe's Guardian Angel/Watcher

[setos_puppy]

oh yes oh good

Team, Taking down Chik-fil-A

[(Anonymous)]

The team finds out about Chick-fil-A and all it stands for (from Nile?), and they decide the company has to go down.

Any level of crack is fine.

Re: Team, Taking down Chik-fil-A

[(Anonymous)]

the lack of fill on this is CRIMINAL