Prompt Post #1

[theoldguardkinkmeme]

To keep the prompt posts manageable in size, new prompts should be added in Prompt Post #2. 

This post remains open, however, for you to link fills or express your excitement over prompts you would like to see filled.

There are still many, many gorgeous prompts in this post that have not yet been written or drawn. For easier browsing, check out the Pinboard.

Remember: 

Any characters, any ship, any trope, any kink is welcome (with the sole exception of human(oid) characters under 14). 

Each prompt gets a new comment directly under the post. Don't use threaded comments for new prompts. Only squee, encouragement, and links to fills go in the comments responding to individual prompts.

Prompts should be posted anonymously.

Please use a header with your character(s)/pairing and a keyword or short phrase (For example: "Andy/Quynh, Make-up sex" or "Nicky/Joe/Booker, first time DP").

 

Comments

Joe/Nicky, rope bondage

[(Anonymous)]

Joe likes getting tied up. Nicky likes having Joe at his mercy.

Joe/m, non-con, 1099, it's Nicky's fault

[(Anonymous)]

At some point in their murderfest, Nicky revives quickly enough to get Joe trussed up and over the back of a horse, and hauls him back to the Crusader lines as a prisoner. The other Italians proceed to do terrible, terrible things to Joe.

Re: Joe/m, non-con, 1099, it's Nicky's fault

[(Anonymous)]

Unf, seconded. PLEASE.

Joe/Nicky hatesex

[(Anonymous)]

Dubcon-y hatesex while trying to kill each other in the Crusades, please and thank you.

Re: Joe/Nicky hatesex

[(Anonymous)]

+1000

Joe/Nicky, Joe worries Nicky's getting bored

[(Anonymous)]

I could go for a fluff fic about the time Joe wondered if maybe Nicky was interested in other people. Nicky is a beautiful man, people flirt with him, and Nicky likes people (and all those things are also true about Joe but this is fluff logic, bear with me), maybe he wants to branch out. Maybe Joe's boring him? Maybe that's just a thing that's supposed to happen after the first three hundred years?

And then Nicky screws Joe's brains out because he's still 400% into Joe, the end.

Re: Joe/Nicky, Joe worries Nicky's getting bored- FILLED

[(Anonymous)]

https://theoldguardkinkmeme.dreamwidth.org/694.html?thread=80822#cmt80822

Andy/Agrippina the Younger

[(Anonymous)]

Andy fucked Agrippina the Younger, y/y?

Nicky/Joe, manhandling

[(Anonymous)]

Pls take advantage of Nicky's canonical height compared to Joe

Re: Nicky/Joe, manhandling

[(Anonymous)]

Pls explain? Do you mean in the book?

Joe/Nicky, shaving

[(Anonymous)]

One of them shaves the other. Sexily?

Re: Joe/Nicky, shaving

[(Anonymous)]

Fuck yes

Anyone, Wound fucking

[(Anonymous)]

To quote a nonny who spoke right to my id, "There's no limit to the number of penetrative options when you're immortal, is there?"

Filthy darkness please. Is it Quynh's revenge torture? Is it the other way the team punishes Booker? You choose! Bonus points for dirty talk about coming inside of the wound/healing with come inside them.

Re: Anyone, Wound fucking

[(Anonymous)]

I need this

Andy/Nile, sparring turns sexy

[(Anonymous)]

Andy and Nile are sparring and it ends up getting sexual. :))

Re: Andy/Nile, sparring turns sexy

[(Anonymous)]

Fuck, yes.

Joe/Nicky, sleeping beauty snuff

[(Anonymous)]

Joe fucking Nicky's corpse as he comes back to life. Either noncon when they met (bonus for language issues) or into their relationship as a game.

Nicky/Joe, hate sex and necrophilia

[(Anonymous)]

During the crusades, one fucks the other after murdering him

Re: Nicky/Joe, hate sex and necrophilia

[(Anonymous)]

ahahahhaa hello kink I didn't know I had until this fandom

Joe/Nicky, breathplay and accidental necrophilia

[(Anonymous)]

Nicky loves erotic asphyxiation and Joe is happy to provide. During an intense session Joe accidentally chockes Nicky and fucks his corpse.

Bonus if Nicky comes back to life as Joe finishes and it feels good for both.

Re: Joe/Nicky, breathplay and accidental necrophilia

[(Anonymous)]

I know I’m late to this prompt but I just wrote the first 2K of this, I’ll probably be posting it this week

Booker/Joe/Nicky, sparring leads to sex

[(Anonymous)]

pre-movie/comics.

They are sparring (all three or just two of them, your choice) and Booker becomes really aroused.

Joe and Nicky decide to help him out.

Fill: Booker/Joe/Nicky, sparring leads to sex

[(Anonymous)]

Filled here! https://theoldguardkinkmeme.dreamwidth.org/694.html?thread=671158#cmt671158

Anyone/Booker, cock and balls torture

[(Anonymous)]

Any member of the team or all of them subjecting Booker to CBT (consensual or dub-con is up to you) with aftercare.

Bonus for the use of a humbler and Booker being desperate for release.

Re: Anyone/Booker, cock and balls torture

[(Anonymous)]

Holy shit, please someone write this.

Andy/Booker/Nile, pegging and double penetration

[(Anonymous)]

Andy and Nile pegging Booker simoultaneously.

Joe and Nicky can be watching.

Re: Andy/Booker/Nile, pegging and double penetration

[(Anonymous)]

YES - this is a great prompt.

Joe/Nicky, villain!Nicky hatesex

[(Anonymous)]

They never became lovers after the crusades and Nicky went his own way to be an immortal villain and he's still a catholic bigot.

They meet again and hatesex ensues.

Nicky/Joe/Booker, daddy kink

[(Anonymous)]

Booker needs punishment from his daddies :)

Joe/Nicky, bites and bruises

[(Anonymous)]

Joe and Nicky having rough sex, watching the bites and bruises heal and making more.

Re: Joe/Nicky, bites and bruises

[(Anonymous)]

Love this

Andy/Quynh, Andy licking honey off Quynh's tits

[(Anonymous)]

That's it that's the prompt.

Re: Andy/Quynh, Andy licking honey off Quynh's tits

[(Anonymous)]

Fill here: https://theoldguardkinkmeme.dreamwidth.org/694.html?thread=1630390#cmt1630390

Nicky/Joe, Joe's loud in bed

[(Anonymous)]

Joe's extremely vocal during sex (when he can afford to be) and Nicky likes making him moan.

Booker/Andy, foot bathing

[(Anonymous)]

Andy lets Booker bathe her feet.

Booker/any, praise kink

[(Anonymous)]

Someone lets Booker know he's good.

Re: Booker/any, praise kink

[(Anonymous)]

Oh please yes

Joe/Nicky, praise kink

[(Anonymous)]

One of them praises, the other blossoms under it.

Joe/Nicky, formalwear

[(Anonymous)]

For whatever reason, the gang is doing a job that involves crashing some super formal event and everyone has to get cleaned up and dressed up - give me Joe and Nicky losing their god damn minds over each other in suits and sneaking off for a quick fuck during the mission (or before, or after, or all three!)

Re: Joe/Nicky, formalwear

[(Anonymous)]

Cuuuute

Joe/Nicky, shirtless Joe

[(Anonymous)]

You know that tumblr post of a shirtless Marwan Kenzari?

https://ladyofrosefire.tumblr.com/post/624169073668947968

Yeah.

Nicky sees Joe shirtless and loses his mind. I don't care if he's never seen it before or seen it a million times. I don't care if he desperately tries to pretend he's not affected or immediately jumps Joe. Just give me something where Nicky's confronted with all of that and has a very strong reaction.

(Okay, so my absolute favourite possibility is the one where they're not together yet and this is the first time Nicky sees Joe like that and basically throws himself at Joe, but for real. I'll take anything.)

Re: Joe/Nicky, shirtless Joe

[(Anonymous)]

Fuck I wish I could write just so I could fill this