theoldguardkinkmeme | Prompt Post #2

To keep the prompt posts more manageable in size for modding, new prompts should be added in Prompt Post #3.

This post remains open, however, for you to link fills or express your excitement over prompts you would like to see filled.

There are still many, many gorgeous prompts in this post that have not yet been written or drawn. For easier browsing, check out the Pinboard.

Remember:

Any characters, any ship, any trope, any kink is welcome (with the sole exception of human(oid) characters under 14).

Each prompt gets a new comment directly under the post. Don't use threaded comments for new prompts. Only squee, encouragement, and links to fills go in the comments responding to individual prompts.

Prompts should be posted anonymously.

Please use a header with your character(s)/pairing and a keyword or short phrase (For example: "Andy/Quynh, Make-up sex" or "Nicky/Joe/Booker, first time DP").

Page 7 of 9 << [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] >>

Threaded | Flat

From: (Anonymous)

Modern AU where Andy lives in an apartment building. Joe, Nile, Booker and Quhyn are her friends who come over for game night. Nicky is Andy's new neighbor who she doesn't see a lot but he's nice enough- Andy even says she might invite him to game night because she doesn't see him with any friends except for some asshole named Keane who she thinks is Nicky's boyfriend

+Andy kinda becomes friends with Nicky because he makes really good baklava but he's always so quiet and reserved when she goes to his apartment to give back the tupperwares and she's seen his boyfriend skulking around. Fr time to time she's heard yelling but when she goes over to check on Nicky he insists everything is okay

++During game night, Booker, Joe, Nile and Quhyn hear a screaming match. Andy just bangs on the wall and yells at them to keep it down, thinking it's nothing. Except, an hour later, they hear more yelling followed by things breaking and Andy thinks she hears Nicky crying his boyfriend is screaming obscenities about Nicky cheating on him with that Andy chick (which are entirely untrue as she's dating Quhyn)

+++They go next door when the fighting gets louder and they kick down the door to her neighbor's apartment to find Keane throwing dishes and trashing the apartment and Nicky is on the floor cowering against the fridge pleading with Keane in Italian- there's bruising on his face and neck and blood coming from his nose and lip- Joe steps between them and stays with Nicky while Quyhn , Booker and Nile try to restrain Keane so Andy can call for help

No immediate Joe/Nicky but maybe a few years or so later when Nicky feels he's ready to be in a relationship again (because trauma doesn't automatically heal overnight) he's dating Joe and more open and Andy can consider him one of her real friends and not just the quiet man who lived in the apartment next door

From: (Anonymous)

We all just accept that they got married the moment it became legal, and they probably did. But between them finding out it's legal and the actual ceremony, Joe goes a little insane trying to find the perfect way to propose.

BONUS POINTS: Joe drives Andy crazy by running every idea by her.

From: (Anonymous)

Their immortality also means they have no refractory period at all.

Down for any possibilities this entails—awkward attempts to explain to a mortal lover why they’re still unsatisfied after round one, Joe/Nicky marathon sex, days-long team orgy, Andy taking advantage of the fact that Booker can always get/stay hard to ride him until she’s come an absurd number of times, you name it.

From: (Anonymous)

Just give me all the quality content of them learning each other’s languages, cooking each other delicacies from home, celebrating each other’s religious festivals together, etc.

From: (Anonymous)

After the inevitable confrontation with Quynh (and epic make-up sex), Andy and Quynh get married. The rest of the team has a field day arranging everything, organising bachelorette parties for both of them, etc.

From: (Anonymous)

Nicky and Joe have been thirsting after Booker for a while but they’ve never asked him to join them because he only ever talked about his wife so they assumed he wasn’t into men. One night (in a happy future after he’s back from exile) Booker casually mentions a fling he had with one of his fellow soldiers back in the Napoleonic Wars, and Joe and Nicky aren’t wasting any more time.

From: (Anonymous)

Early on after Booker joins the team, he walks in on Joe and Nicky. He leaves in a hurry, but not before he gets quite an eyeful. Andy takes one look at his face (and the tent in his pants) and is like “yeah, I know, it’s infuriatingly hot, right?”

And that’s how they start a friends with benefits arrangement to take the edge off every time Joe and Nicky can’t wait for privacy (which is often).

From: (Anonymous)

Andy may no longer be worshipped as a god, but the team is happy to get on their knees for her.

From: (Anonymous)

Joe spanking Nicky during sex.

That’s all.

From: (Anonymous)

As punishment, Joe comes on Nicky's face and forbids him from washing it off for the rest of the day.

The rest of the team can participate as well.

From: (Anonymous)

Joe has a really big cock. Nicky struggles to take it. Every. Damn. Time. That's it.

From: (Anonymous)

Keane keeps Nicky for weeks, constantly stimulating his cock and keeping him on the verge of orgasm. Nicky can come anytime - as long as he "consents" to getting fucked.

The worst part is that hes actually considering it.

From: (Anonymous)

Nicky is de-aged. Could be gradual as a result of what happened in the lab, and the others observe it over time. Or there is another incident and when they rescue him he is roughly in his late teens, or twenty or so, but with all his memories intact. Joe is torn between wanting to fuck his fresh faced lover through the floor, and wanting to protect Nicky from everything (including him). Nicky realises he is going to have to seduce his lover if he is ever going to be with Joe again. But he has no game. Like none at all. Cue the others trying to help. (Bonus points if you can get Copley in on it.) Some Joe pov would be the icing on the cake.

From: (Anonymous)

Before they ever got together, Joe would fuck anything that stood still for too long. In every town or village they came to he'd find a man or woman to take to bed.

Nicky, fiercely closeted and in absolute denial about his feelings, would always find a way to peek into the room and masturbate furiously, hoping he could be the one riding Joe's enormous cock.

One day, Joe catches him.

From: (Anonymous)

Early days Joe and Nicky have started traveling together, they respect each other and like each other and they're not sure if there's more there yet but they both want there to be. Cue dozens of unfortunate situations of mutual pining and intense frustration, such as

- oh no, Nicky has been tied up by bandits, Joe has to kneel down in front of him to undo the ropes and Nicky has to pretend Joe looking up at him from down there isn't Doing Things to him

- Nicky wants to know more about Joe's culture and Joe ends up reciting romantic poetry Nicky doesn't even understand thinking about how much it applies to their situation

- bathing together and being torn between respecting each other's privacy and haha-we're-just-guys-being-dudes-who-cares-who-sees-who-naked except they really, really, really care

followed ideally by an explosive release of tension

From: (Anonymous)

Too tired/not in the mood to have sex but enough in the mood to just lazily make out before going to sleep.

From: (Anonymous)

After killing the guards in the van, when they're on the place, Joe keeps mouthing off to Keane. Hitting Joe doesn't make him stop, so Keane decides that he's going to take every word out of Joe's mouth out on Nicky.

From: (Anonymous)

Joe and Nicky get attacked by homophobes, who soon realise they chose the wrong couple to try and beat down.

From: (Anonymous)

I found out the name of the cashier is Celeste

Anywho after patching up Andy and whatnot, Andy decides Celeste is trust worthy and the team become regulars at her little convenience store, enough so that they sometimes use the store as a base when they have missions in that area

+Nile gets a secondary job there as a cover but ends up staying to work when they have jobs there

++Nicky and Joe make Celeste some sort of sweets to celebrate her birthday

+++Booker will feign shopping if he thinks some guy who's up to no good is there when Celeste has the night shift

++++Andy walks Celeste home when it's dark to make sure she gets home safe

From: (Anonymous)

Back in the day it was usually Andy/Quynh and Nicky/Joe, but casual, friendly group sex would happen occasionally. At some point after they lose Quynh (long enough that the wound isn’t still super fresh), Nicky and Joe wonder if they should invite Andy to bed with them again, or if it will just be weird and awkward for her without Quynh.

(I could honestly go either way on a Quynh-less threesome turning out good, bad, or a little of both, just curious to see where someone might take this idea!)

From: (Anonymous)

The group is at a club and a drunk guy (Nicky) accidentally spills a drink on Joe but afterwards he loses the guy in the crowd. Joe sits himself at the bar and he sees the cute Italian guy around during the night

When they all go to leave for the night,Andy and Booker point out something down the street and they realize it's the drunk guy from the club being crowded against the wall and fighting off someone

- Joe doesn't know who the guy is but Andy finds his wallet so they take their new friend Nicky to their place to sleep it off

-- Nicky wakes up hungover in a handsome stranger's apartment but the guy Joe and this Andy girl were super nice and he feels bad for causing them so much trouble

From: (Anonymous)

Anything. Seriously.

(But I'll love you forever for giving me Booker wearing one of Nicky's hoodies.)

From: (Anonymous)

So I saw in an interview Luca Marinello said he sometimes doesn't understand British accents when talking to British people and Nicky was very quiet when they first meet Merrick.

So Merrick is being all smarmy and British and condescending and he calls Nicky a mouse. Nicky looked super confused and Joe says "He thinks you're a mouse, Nicky"

To that, Merrick moves to grab Nicky's face, talking about how between Nicky and Joe, Nicky is much more meek in comparison to Joe

When Merrick grabs Nicky's face during his whole mouse speech, he makes the mistake the mistake of shoving his fingers in Nicky's mouth so Nicky bites him- while Nicky doesn't fully understand the British accent, he understands a man trying to weild power where he shouldn't

From: (Anonymous)

Nicky gets sexually assaulted by one of the guards while in the lab but nobody knows about it. They kill the man responsible during the escape anyway. Up to the writer how bad the assault was.

Nicky doesn’t say a word of it to anyone, especially Joe, decides to deal with it by himself. He makes a slow recovery but then the team decides to re-admit Booker believing that they need to be there for him. Nicky is against it because seeing Booker is triggering to him but the rest outvotes him. He gets into fights with Joe over it but is scared to lose him, so eventually gives up.

Heavy angst with Bookers presence actively hindering Nicky’s recovery. For example, constantly hearing how it was their fault that Booker betrayed them, makes Nicky believe that his assault was his own fault. (Maybe even as far as starting to believe it was an actual punishment from God for failing Booker) Or Nicky freaking out during a mission thinking that Booker betrayed them again is seen as him endangering the mission on purpose, to undermine Booker, so now Nicky thinks he’s a liability to the team.

His behaviour is seen as him being stubborn and unforgiving.

Bonus:
- Joe was in contact with Booker behind Nicky’s back
- Joe makes a speech or two about how disappointed he is in Nicky
- someone making comments re: forgiveness in context of Nicky’s religious believes (ie: God would want you to forgive, I thought Catholics believe in forgiveness, you’re only religious when it suits you etc)

No team bashing. They have no idea what happened, don’t even suspect, believe that helping Booker’s recovery is their duty and Nicky is just being a stubborn ass the hi need to get over himself

From: (Anonymous)

I'd really live to see something where Nicky was the one to initiate sex the first time. Maybe Joe (Yusuf at the time) has never been with a man, maybe he's uncertain that his interest is returned, maybe Nicolo just runs out of patience first... however you want to frame it, I just want Nicky to be the one to make the first move.