theoldguardkinkmeme | Prompt Post #3

Prompt Post #3

To keep the prompt posts more manageable in size for modding, this post is closed to new prompts for now. The next prompt post is going to open on August, 24.

This post remains open, however, for you to link fills or express your excitement over prompts you would like to see filled.

There are still many, many gorgeous prompts in this post that have not yet been written or drawn. For easier browsing, check out the Pinboard.

Remember:

Any characters, any ship, any trope, any kink is welcome (with the sole exception of sexual scenarios involving human(oid) characters under 14).

Each prompt gets a new comment directly under the post. Don't use threaded comments for new prompts. Only squee, encouragement, and links to fills go in the comments responding to individual prompts.

Prompts should be posted anonymously.

Please use a header with your character(s)/pairing and a keyword or short phrase (For example: "Andy/Quynh, Make-up sex" or "Nicky/Joe/Booker, first time DP").

Threaded | Top-Level Comments Only

Unf, hot! Seconded.

Argh, I want to write this but I have two other stories ongoing. I will see what I can do. Hopefully someone else will also be tempted.

Ok this is HOT

(Inspired by the prompt above and the Joe Has Amnesia and Hits on Nicky one.)

Nicky gets temporary amnesia when he gets shot in the head, but knows he's part of the Team and automatically joins them. He doesn't know he and Joe are together. Cue Nicky, post-Merrick, recovering at a safehouse and hitting on Joe constantly.

Yes! Please! So sweet!

Oh, I'm getting all the thoughts and feels for this one.

Joe, who sometimes takes others to his bed, oblivious to the effect it has on Nicky.

Nile, finding out, that Nicky hasn't had another lover since Joe left him, and is willing to just take whatever Joe will give him.

Then Nicky and Nile are at a museum or an art gallery, and someone hits on Nicky. When he asks Nicky out to dinner, Nile can see that Nicky's going to turn him down, so she dives in and accepts for him.

When they get back to the safehouse/hotel, Nile starts going through Nicky's clothes and when Andy asks what she's doing, she tells them that Nicky has a hot date with a hot guy and that she's not going to let him out looking like a suburban dad.

And maybe it's then Joe realises that he's been lying to himself, and the possibility that Nicky could be with someone else, even though Joe has done exactly that, pains him.

Nicky sucks dick like a champ with 900 years of experience, Joe blows his load in his mouth, and Nicky makes out with him and feeds his come back into his mouth via tongue on tongue action.

That's it. That's the prompt.

Nicky is the quiet, older student in the class. The others don't know much about him except for the accent and that he's mentioned a husband.

And then, for reasons, armed gunmen storm the classroom. (Maybe the child of someone important is also a student.)

Nothing happens for a few hours beyond some threats. Then, one of the gunmen shoots one of the students in the leg and suddenly Nicky is taking them all down, just as the rest of the team charge into the lecture hall. (They'd been outside with the families of the other students being held, while the police tried to talk to the gunmen, but all bets were off once they heard the gunshot.)

Nicky does something incredibly dangerous and stupid. Joe loses his cool and bends him over his knee for a spanking.

Any level of consent and enjoyment.

Nicky did terrible things in the name of his god, during the Crusades. Joe is aware of these and he knows how much atonement Nicky has done since.

Something happens that makes the rest of the team aware of what he did. It doesn't change how Andy views him because she knows what life is like and who Nicky was back then isn't who he is now.

But Nike can't reconcile the Nicky she knows and loves with the man who did those things. It colours how she views him, until Joe sits down with her and explains how he sees Nicky.

Are you thinking as a first time, or them having a domestic discipline type of relationship?

OP

Wait I lied, I do have more thoughts. The main prompt is the prompt, but if you want an more guidance/ideas, what about the first time they do this? It was heat of the moment, not discussed before, Nicky is just divinely inspired (lol) to do it and Joe is shocked at first because it's filthy and he didn't know his Nicolo would be into that.

OP - honestly, up to you. I'm fine either way :)

No matter what, Joe always without fails suddenly sweeps Nicky up in his arms, kicks open the door and carries Nicky inside like a bride on their wedding day

I wanna see a five times type thing

-bonus one of the times they had just escaped from being kidnapped and Nicky didn't have time to get the tape off around his wrists and ankles during the escape

Immortal!Keane joins the team, regardless of Joe's very vocal protests. It's not an ideal situation, but Andy believes (and Nile agrees) that leaving him out there is even more dangerous than welcoming him into the group. The only person who seems willing to give him a fair chance is Nicky.

For a few months, everything seems to be going okay...ish. Tension is dissipating, Keane is less insufferable, and Joe can *almost* get through an entire day without threatening to kill him.

And that's pretty much when Keane decides to take advantage of Nicky's kindness.

Why and how is up to filler. Maybe he just gets drunk and feels alone. Maybe he envies what he and Joe have. Or maybe he just wants to make Joe mad by seducing his partner - and then gets enfuriating when he can't.

Whatever reason and however he does it, Nicky is in absolute shock. He says he'll tell the team, but Keane is very manipulative, saying things like "they know you're a better fighter than me, how *exactly* did I force you into it?" and "your boyfriend will never look at you the same way".

And so Nicky stays quiet.

Where do they go from here?

-slides a twenty across the table-

Please, wonderful and admirable writers, let Joe get DP'd.

Double pen, with character of your choice. Nicky is preferred but optional.

Is it safe, sane and consentsual? Is Nicky calling the shots while Joe struggles to breathe?

Or is it rougher, more cruel, and Nicky has to watch as strange men spread Joe's legs, and fuck him hard and fast? Joe's eyes swollen shut but healing, and he's making the most obscene sounds, and when another cock presses in, he screams.

All I want is Joe getting dp'd and crying because he's overwhelmed.

Loving it! I'm shipping.

So it's France. It's the Napoleanic wars. Booker realized he can't die and on top of that he keeps dreaming of total strangers. A woman with dark hair and a labrys who loves vodka. A stranger screaming at the bottom of the ocean

And two men from opposing sides of a centuries old conflict, going at it like rabbits

When Booker finally meets these people, he makes sure to tell at them for giving him the worst experiences he's ever had because he really doesn't want to pop an awkward boner in his sleep every night

(No Booker being in love with them please best simply too drunk to handle Nicky and Joe's lovey-dovey shit and Andy finds it hilarious)

OP: And that Nike is, of course, meant to be Nile. Damn fingers.

I wrote something to it ;)

https://archiveofourown.org/works/25954591

Edited 2020-08-18 06:01 (UTC)

That sounds awesome. I. Want. It.

After being chained, ziptied and shot and tortured, Joe makes sure to let Nicky know how much he loves him by kissing his wrists where the ziptied cut into Nicky so deep they bled

He kisses his ankles, trying to lick away the metal residue of the chains and tongues his mouth to rid Nicky of the taste of gunpowder and anywhere the straps of the table held him down

Through some throat injury that didn't heal right or quickly, or through selective mutism if you prefer, Joe temporarily (or permanently if you really want) loses his voice. It's hard for everyone to adjust, because they're all so used to Joe being the talkative one, the one who keeps them entertained and comforted and grounded. But for Joe, the hardest thing is not being able to tell Nicky how much he loves him, his favourite activity in the world. How does Nicky help him deal with this?

(People who are mute live very rich and fulfilling lives and there's nothing inherently bad or broken about being mute, I'm just interested in this happening to Joe specifically and how he as a character deals with it, not in ableist attitudes about how all muteness is a tragedy, just for clarification!)

Nicky and Joe are so in love that it's sickening. It's a relationship that has stood the rest of time, where the others have gone cold or bitter or lost

Nile may be new to the team, but she sees how Andy and Booker protect Joe and Nicky from people who want to destroy what Joe and Nicky have, even if they aren't aware of it

Everyone is lounging around and relaxing at a safehouse. Nicky steals Joe's iconic blue shirt after his shower and slips it on

Joe was still.in the shower when Nicky was getting dressed. He walks out wet and shirtless, to find Nicky wearing it

And he thinks Nicky looks absolutely, devastatingly sexy in his clothes so he's leaning over Nicky, caging him in where he sits and they're lazily making out

Booker throws popcorn at them for ruining the game on TV but they don't care as Joe straddles Nicky's lap to keep kissing him

Threaded | Top-Level Comments Only

Page 15 of 21

Prompt Post #3

Re: Breast feeding kink - comfort Andy/Nicky

Re: Joe/Nicky AU, seduction, dubcon

Re: Nicolò/Yusuf + others - oral sex

Joe/Nicky, Temporary Amnesia, Nicky Hits on Joe

Re: Joe/Nicky, Temporary Amnesia, Nicky Hits on Joe

Re: Joe/Nicky, one-sided break up, pining heartbroken Nicky, angst

Joe/Nicky, snowballing

CollegeStudent!Nicky, Nicky being a badass

Joe/Nicky - spanking as punishment

Joe/Nicky, Nicky's Crusader Days

Re: Joe/Nicky - spanking as punishment

Re: Joe/Nicky, snowballing

Re: Joe/Nicky - spanking as punishment

Joe/Nicky + Bridal Carry Over The Threshold Of Every Safehouse

Immortal!Keane/Nicky - non-con when Keane is part of the team

Joe/Any - DP+Overwhelmed (noncon optional?)

Re: Keane/Booker, immortal!Keane finds a friend

Nicky/Joe + Booker Too Drunk To Deal With Lovey Dovey Shit

Re: Joe/Nicky, Nicky's Crusader Days

FILL: Joe/Nicky, Intercrural Sex

Re: Joe/Nicky, snowballing

Joe/Nicky + Kissing Away The Pain

Whole team, Joe/Nicky, Joe loses his voice

Nile & Booker & Andy + Protecting Nicky & Joe

Nicky/Joe + Nicky Wearing Joe's Blue Shirt