theoldguardkinkmeme

It was Joe or Nicky that was captured and put in the iron maiden in the ocean. The other one would not stop looking, would obsess over finding their lover again so much he hurt himself by not eating or sleeping for days at a time. Andy and Quynh could not stand to see him like that for forever, especially not with the new French immortal they all started dreaming about recently. So they somehow make him forget that the other man in the ocean ever existed. This was not something they decided on lightly, they did it because they felt they had to, Joe/Nicky was endangering all of them while searching. People were starting to notice the man searching the oceans who was not aging, not getting hurt and not dying.