Nicky gets off on being humiliated when he gets fucked. When Nicky needs it, Joe fucks him in front of the others while the rest of the team all call out humiliating things about Nicky.

None of them speak to him directly, just comments to each other and Joe about "look at that loose hole just swallow Joe's cock," or "how desperate it is to be fucked," or asking Joe how he can bring himself to fuck something so slutty.

Afterwards, when Nicky is dressed and the scene is over, everyone is very tactile and huggy with Nicky for the next couple of hours, especially Joe.