Having a body that constantly heals itself means that every time Joe fucks Nicky, even if it's multiple times in one night, it feels like the first time all over again. It also means that he has to spend a lot of time opening him up for it between rounds, which Joe thinks is hot as hell because he loves the sounds Nicky makes when he's riding his fingers, but sometimes he wishes he could keep Nicky's hole open and ready for him whenever he wants it. The discovery of the butt plug is a serious game changer.

(I h/c them as verse, but for the purposes of the prompt I'm feeling some bottom Nicky pls)