Since their bodies always heal, Nicky is just as tight as the first time Joe fucked him almost a thousand years ago. Instead of finding this a nuisance (due to all the pain and preparation required to get through sex every time), Nicky decides to have fun with it.

Cue immortal husbands roleplaying several scenarios where Joe deflowers his beloved in a myriad of ways.

Feel free to switch the roles, more than fine with Top!Nicky.